Babysitting The Brat | Samantha Hayes, Chloe Cherry, Lily Rader | 2018

When Chloe Cherry storms into the bedroom, Samantha Hayes wonders why her girlfriend looks so stressed out. Chloe explains that her stepsister, Lily Rader, has gotten into some trouble and their parents grounded her. Chloe and Samantha were supposed to have the weekend to themselves and now they’re stuck with Lily. Samantha proposes they give her some money to get a ticket to the movies. It dawns on Chloe that this might actually work, and she’s relieved. The girls go to Lily’s room to tell her.

They catch her taking partially nude selfies: Lily tells them to come back later, she’s busy. Chloe and Samantha tell Lily that they got her movie tickets. Her eyes light but she suspects something is up. Why are they being so nice? She wonders what they could possibly get out of it. They explain that they claim to have a lot of studying to do and want the house to themselves to make sure they get it all done. Lily isn’t buying any of it but happily takes the money and the tickets. The girls go back to their room, ecstatic that their plan worked, and start making out on the bed. What they don’t know is that Lily is at the door snapping pictures of them.

When Lily enters the room giggling, Chloe freaks out, asking why she’s not at the movies. Lily shows her the pictures and demands a weekly pay for her silence. The girls comply but she wants more than just money: she wants Chloe’s girlfriend Samantha. She’s tired of being the black sheep of the family and wants a taste of what Chloe has, a hot girlfriend. The girls initially refuse, but when Lily tells them she’s gonna text her parents the pictures, they agree. She kisses Samantha and then demands that Samantha gives her an orgasm. The girls realize pretty quickly that Lily won’t stop until she gets everything she wants. They acquiesce to her every demand.